Pope Francis’ Successor: Tradition & Change

Here in Chicago, as elsewhere across the nation, news of Pope Leo XIV’s Holy Thursday foot-washing ceremony has stirred a quiet debate. While seemingly a simple act of humility mirroring the actions of Jesus Christ, the fact that he washed the feet of twelve priests, rather than the traditionally chosen twelve members of the laity, has prompted discussion. It’s a return to tradition, but also a deliberate departure from the approach of his predecessor, Pope Francis, who consistently chose to wash the feet of prisoners, refugees, and others on the margins of society. The ripple effects of this shift are being felt even here, in the heart of the Midwest, prompting reflection on the evolving symbolism within the Catholic Church.

A Historical Context: Foot-Washing and Papal Tradition

The practice of foot-washing, or *mandatum*, originates from the Last Supper, as recounted in the Gospel of John. Jesus washed the feet of his apostles as a demonstration of love and service. For centuries, the ceremony was primarily performed by bishops on Maundy Thursday, washing the feet of twelve poor people, symbolizing Christ’s humility and service to all. Pope Francis, elected in 2013, dramatically altered this practice, consistently selecting individuals from marginalized communities – a move widely interpreted as a signal of his commitment to social justice and inclusivity. His choices often made headlines, challenging conventional interpretations of the ritual. The Archdiocese of Chicago, under the leadership of Cardinal Blase Cupich, has historically mirrored many of Pope Francis’s progressive stances, making the change in practice particularly noticeable for local parishioners.

View this post on Instagram

Pope Francis’s Legacy and Pope Leo’s Course Correction

Pope Francis served as the head of the Catholic Church and sovereign of Vatican City until his death on April 21, 2025. His papacy was marked by a consistent emphasis on pastoral care, social justice, and interfaith dialogue. He was ordained as a priest in 1969 and rose through the ranks of the Jesuit order, eventually becoming Archbishop of Buenos Aires. His decision to wash the feet of those on the periphery was seen as a tangible expression of his theological priorities. Pope Leo XIV, succeeding him, appears to be signaling a return to more traditional interpretations of the ritual. This isn’t necessarily a rejection of Pope Francis’s values, but rather a different emphasis. Some theologians suggest it’s a reaffirmation of the importance of the priesthood and the sacramental nature of the Church. The impact of this shift is being discussed within institutions like the Catholic Theological Union at the University of Chicago, a leading center for Catholic theological education.

Theological Interpretations and Local Reactions

The choice to wash the feet of priests, rather than laypeople, has sparked debate among theologians and lay Catholics alike. Some argue that it underscores the unique role of the priesthood as representatives of Christ and servants of the Church. Others express concern that it reinforces a hierarchical structure that can distance the Church from the everyday lives of its members. Here in Chicago, parishes with strong social outreach programs, such as those affiliated with the Society of Jesus, may be more inclined to view the change with caution. Conversely, parishes with a more traditional liturgical focus might welcome it as a return to established norms. The debate is unfolding in church bulletins, parish council meetings, and online forums, reflecting the diverse perspectives within the Chicago Catholic community. The University of Saint Mary of the Lake in Mundelein, the seminary for the Archdiocese of Chicago, is likely hosting discussions on the theological implications of this change among its students.

Navigating the Shifting Landscape: A Local Resource Guide

Given my background in analyzing the intersection of religious trends and community impact, and understanding how these shifts can affect individuals and families here in Chicago, I recognize that this evolving symbolism might prompt deeper questions for some. If you discover yourself grappling with these changes and seeking guidance, here are three types of local professionals who can offer support and clarity:

1. Catholic Pastoral Counselors:: Seem for counselors specifically trained in Catholic theology and ethics. They can provide a safe and supportive space to explore your feelings about the changes within the Church and how they relate to your personal faith journey. Credentials to look for include a Master’s degree in Counseling with a specialization in pastoral care, and ideally, endorsement from the Archdiocese of Chicago.
2. Canon Law Experts:: If you’re interested in the legal and procedural aspects of Church governance, a canon lawyer can offer valuable insights. They can explain the historical precedents and theological justifications for the changes in practice. Seek individuals with a Doctorate in Canon Law (JCD) and experience advising parishes or dioceses.
3. Spiritual Directors:: A spiritual director can help you deepen your relationship with God and discern your own calling within the Church. They can provide guidance on how to navigate the complexities of faith in a changing world. Look for directors who have completed formal training in spiritual direction and have a strong understanding of Catholic spirituality.

Ready to find trusted professionals? Browse our complete directory of top-rated the vatican experts in the Chicago area today.