RuPaul’s Drag Race Season 18 Episode 9 Recap: Musical Theater Queens Rise
The question of whether formal training enhances or hinders a drag queen’s performance on RuPaul’s Drag Race has been a recurring debate among fans, and it took center stage on the latest episode, . Episode 9, titled “Fannie: The Hard Knock Ball Rusical,” saw the queens tackle a musical theater challenge, prompting a re-examination of the value placed on polish versus raw charisma.
For years, a pattern emerged where queens with extensive performing arts backgrounds – Alexis Michelle, Jan, Rosé, and others – consistently delivered technically proficient performances but struggled to connect with RuPaul on a deeper level. The perception was that these queens were performers applying their skills to drag, rather than drag queens who happened to be skilled performers. This tension, as one observer noted, suggested a rejection of the “spirit of drag” – a haven for misfits – by those who approached it with a highly refined, conservatory-trained sensibility.
However, the rise of the “Rusical” – increasingly elaborate and professionally produced musical challenges – has begun to shift the dynamic. Recent Rusicals, referencing classics like The Sound of Music, Wicked, and A Chorus Line, demand a level of vocal and theatrical skill that previously wasn’t as crucial. This season’s Rusical, “Fannie: The Hard Knock Ball,” a take on Annie and ballroom culture, continued that trend.
This week, two queens, Myki Meeks and Jane Don’t, strategically positioned themselves as “misfit toys” from the world of musical theater. Both acknowledged their training but emphasized a desire to escape the constraints of that world, framing their drag as a liberation. This narrative resonated, suggesting a new path for classically trained queens to embrace their skills while still embodying the rebellious spirit of drag.
The episode opened with the queens processing the previous week’s elimination of Mia Starr, revealing that RuPaul’s critique about a lack of self-awareness had struck a chord. Mia’s struggles with addiction were also addressed, with Athena, another queen, highlighted as a source of support. A mini-challenge, sponsored by Grindr, provided some lighthearted distraction before the main event.
The Rusical challenge tasked the queens with casting themselves in “Fannie: The Hard Knock Ball.” A minor conflict arose when both Myki and Nini Coco vied for the lead role of “Fannie.” While Myki possessed the stronger vocal ability, Nini initially hesitated to relinquish the part before ultimately conceding. The rehearsals showcased Myki’s vocal prowess and Jane Don’t’s overall stage presence, while Discord struggled with choreography and Athena’s vocal performance was deemed lacking.
The runway category was “beige,” a surprisingly challenging theme that tested the queens’ creativity. Darlene’s tweed ensemble stood out as a high point, while Myki’s monochromatic gaze washed her out. Juicy’s Iris Van Herpen-inspired outfit was elegant, and Nini’s wig was a standout. Jane’s Mae West-inspired look was deemed flawless.
During the Rusical performance, Myki excelled as “Fannie,” delivering a nuanced performance that avoided caricature. Jane also impressed, while Kenya Pleaser’s vocal performance commanded attention despite some limitations in her stage presence. Juicy struggled with vocals but shone in choreography, while Athena’s performance was criticized. Nini and Discord’s performances were largely forgettable.
Jane Don’t was declared the winner, marking her second win of the season. Myki’s performance was also highly praised, and a double win was considered. Athena, Juicy, and Discord landed in the bottom three, with Discord receiving largely positive feedback for improvement. Athena was eliminated after a lip-sync to Benny Blanco, Selena Gomez, and Gracie Abrams’ “Call Me When You Break Up,” a song that proved unsuited to the queens’ strengths. The elimination was particularly poignant given the close bond between Athena and Juicy.
The episode also included a brief segment featuring guest judge Benny Blanco, who navigated the challenge of complimenting the queens’ physiques with characteristic awkwardness.
Looking ahead, Myki Meeks is emerging as a strong contender, while Nini Coco remains a potential frontrunner. The fate of Juicy, despite her wins, remains uncertain as she grapples with finding her unique voice. Darlene’s potential for a breakout performance is also being watched closely.
As one fan shared, the season is still lacking a clear standout star. The absence of a dominant personality leaves the competition wide open, with several queens vying for the crown.